Skip to vehicle Listings
Online car buying built around you. Shop Now

Used Toyota Cars for Sale in Shirley, NY

11967
Filters (2)
Items 1 to 2 of 17.
    Sponsored by Atlantic Toyota
    Certified 2024 Toyota Corolla GR w/ Performance Package
    36,992
    See estimated payment
    Great Price
    Similar Match
    Dealer Logo
    63View Vehicles

    302 Matches

    Used 2023 Toyota Corolla LE w/ Carpet Mat Package (TMS)
    18,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    Used 2024 Toyota 4Runner Limited
    Used
    • Limited
    • 13K mi
    51,988
    See payment
    Used 2022 Toyota Highlander XLE
    32,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    My Wallet

    Find it Fast.

    Keep it Affordable.

    Credit Rating
    Trade-In Value
    Get My Kelley Blue Book® CarValue
    Get My Payoff Quote

    $

    Based on 4.5% APR for mos.
    Price Drop
    Used 2015 Toyota RAV4 LE
    Used
    • LE
    • 81K mi
    14,595
    See payment
    Great Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2020 Toyota RAV4 XLE w/ All Weather Liner Package
    Used
    • XLE
    • 27K mi
    26,395
    See payment
    Great Price
    Newly Listed
    Used 2008 Toyota Land Cruiser
    55,000
    See payment
    Advertisement
    Price Drop
    Used 2017 Toyota Corolla iM w/ All-Weather Mat Package
    13,895
    See payment
    Good Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2018 Toyota RAV4 SE w/ Power Extra Value Package
    Used
    • SE
    • 89K mi
    18,195
    See payment
    Great Price
    Used 2023 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro
    Used
    • TRD Pro
    • 33K mi
    35,295
    See payment
    Great Price
    Used 2006 Toyota Prius
    Used
    • 175K mi
     Hybrid
    3,300
    See payment
    Great Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2023 Toyota Highlander XLE
    33,200
    See payment
    Great Price
    Advertisement
    Price Drop
    Used 2022 Toyota Highlander Bronze Edition
    Used
    • Bronze Edition
    • 42K mi
     Hybrid
    33,977
    See payment
    Great Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota Prius Prime XLE
    Used
    • XLE
    • 62K mi
     Plug-In Hybrid
    19,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2018 Toyota Highlander SE
    24,145
    See payment
    Great Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2020 Toyota Corolla SE
    16,303
    See payment
    Great Price
    Advertisement
    Newly Listed
    Used 2023 Toyota RAV4 LE
    Used
    • LE
    • 38K mi
    26,498
    See payment
    Great Price
    Newly Listed
    Used 2025 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road
    Used
    • TRD Off-Road
    • 14K mi
    40,560
    See payment
    Good Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota RAV4 XLE Premium
    Used
    • XLE Premium
    • 48K mi
    28,989
    See payment
    Good Price
    Used 2009 Toyota Camry XLE
    Used
    • XLE
    • 124K mi
    7,999
    See payment
    High Demand360°
    Used 2023 Toyota bZ4X XLE
    Used
    • XLE
    • 28K mi
     Electric
    17,295
    See payment
    Great Price
    Used 2019 Toyota Prius XLE w/ Advanced Technology Package
    Used
    • XLE
    • 95K mi
     Hybrid
    17,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    Newly Listed
    Certified 2023 Toyota Camry XSE w/ Navigation Package
     Toyota Gold Certified
    • XSE
    • 28K mi
    35,567
    See payment
    Good Price
    Newly Listed
    Certified 2023 Toyota Crown Platinum
     Toyota Gold Certified
    • Platinum
    • 22K mi
     Hybrid
    38,995
    See payment
    Good Price
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota Highlander XLE
    32,604
    See payment
    Great Price
    Used 2024 Toyota RAV4 XLE w/ Convenience Package
    Used
    • XLE
    • 59K mi
    30,995
    See payment
    Price Drop
    Used 2023 Toyota Highlander XLE
    36,626
    See payment
    Good Price
    360°
    Used 2022 Toyota Prius LE
    Used
    • LE
    • 43K mi
     Hybrid
    16,595
    See payment
    Great Price
    Used 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander AWD
    42,145
    See payment
    Great Price
    Advertisement

    Used Toyota for Sale by Model

    View All Models
    <!--{"relevance":[false,{"relevanceVersion":"default"}]}-->