Autotrader Logo
Skip to vehicle Listings
Online car buying built around you. Shop Now

Used Toyota Cars for Sale in Shirley, NY

11967
Filters (2)
Items 1 to 2 of 17.
    Sponsored by Atlantic Toyota
    Hide
    Certified 2024 Toyota Corolla GR w/ Performance Package
    36,992
    See estimated payment
    Great Price
    Similar Match
    Atlantic Toyota
    (631) 517-4889
    Call
    Dealer Logo
    63View Vehicles

    302 Matches

    Used 2023 Toyota Corolla LE w/ Carpet Mat Package (TMS)
    Used

    2023 Toyota Corolla

    • LE
    • 29K mi
    18,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Sponsored by Stream Auto Outlet Islip
    • 18.5 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2024 Toyota 4Runner Limited
    Used

    2024 Toyota 4Runner

    • Limited
    • 13K mi
    51,988
    See payment
    No Accidents
    Sponsored by Lexus of Smithtown
    • 15.39 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2022 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2022 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 44K mi
    32,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Sponsored by Riverhead Ford
    • 13.27 mi. away
    Call
    My Wallet

    Find it Fast.

    Keep it Affordable.

    Credit Rating
    Trade-In Value
    Get My Kelley Blue Book® CarValue
    Get My Payoff Quote

    $

    Based on 4.5% APR for mos.
    Price Drop
    Used 2015 Toyota RAV4 LE
    Used

    2015 Toyota RAV4

    • LE
    • 81K mi
    14,595
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    Autoland USA
    • 10.17 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2020 Toyota RAV4 XLE w/ All Weather Liner Package
    Used

    2020 Toyota RAV4

    • XLE
    • 27K mi
    26,395
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Autoland USA
    • 10.17 mi. away
    Call
    Newly Listed
    Used 2008 Toyota Land Cruiser
    Used

    2008 Toyota Land Cruiser

    • 7K mi
    55,000
    See payment
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 18.33 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Advertisement
    Price Drop
    Used 2017 Toyota Corolla iM w/ All-Weather Mat Package
    Used

    2017 Toyota Corolla

    • iM
    • 75K mi
    13,895
    See payment
    Good Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    Autoland USA
    • 10.17 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2018 Toyota RAV4 SE w/ Power Extra Value Package
    Used

    2018 Toyota RAV4

    • SE
    • 89K mi
    18,195
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    Autoland USA
    • 10.17 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2023 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro
    Used

    2023 Toyota Tacoma

    • TRD Pro
    • 33K mi
    35,295
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    Nissan 112 Certified
    • 6.96 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2006 Toyota Prius
    Used

    2006 Toyota Prius

    • 175K mi
     Hybrid
    3,300
    See payment
    Great Price
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 23.04 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Price Drop
    Used 2023 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2023 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 38K mi
    33,200
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Smithtown Nissan
    • 14.92 mi. away
    Call
    Advertisement
    Price Drop
    Used 2022 Toyota Highlander Bronze Edition
    Used

    2022 Toyota Highlander

    • Bronze Edition
    • 42K mi
     Hybrid
    33,977
    See payment
    Great Price
    Riverhead Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
    • 12.73 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota Prius Prime XLE
    Used

    2021 Toyota Prius Prime

    • XLE
    • 62K mi
     Plug-In Hybrid
    19,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Stevens 112 Ford
    • 7.16 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2018 Toyota Highlander SE
    Used

    2018 Toyota Highlander

    • SE
    • 53K mi
    24,145
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Baron Honda
    • 7.27 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2020 Toyota Corolla SE
    Used

    2020 Toyota Corolla

    • SE
    • 51K mi
    16,303
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    Competition Subaru of Smithtown Loaner Cars
    • 15.64 mi. away
    Call
    Advertisement
    Newly Listed
    Used 2023 Toyota RAV4 LE
    Used

    2023 Toyota RAV4

    • LE
    • 38K mi
    26,498
    See payment
    Great Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Competition Subaru of Smithtown Loaner Cars
    • 15.64 mi. away
    Call
    Newly Listed
    Used 2025 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road
    Used

    2025 Toyota Tacoma

    • TRD Off-Road
    • 14K mi
    40,560
    See payment
    Good Price
    No Accidents
    Hertz Rent2Buy Smithtown, NY
    • Buy Online
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota RAV4 XLE Premium
    Used

    2021 Toyota RAV4

    • XLE Premium
    • 48K mi
    28,989
    See payment
    Good Price
    No Accidents
    Sayville Ford
    • 10.52 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2009 Toyota Camry XLE
    Used

    2009 Toyota Camry

    • XLE
    • 124K mi
    7,999
    See payment
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 17.14 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    High Demand360°
    Used 2023 Toyota bZ4X XLE
    Used

    2023 Toyota bZ4X

    • XLE
    • 28K mi
     Electric
    17,295
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    PRISTINE MITSUBISHI
    • 20.88 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2019 Toyota Prius XLE w/ Advanced Technology Package
    Used

    2019 Toyota Prius

    • XLE
    • 95K mi
     Hybrid
    17,995
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Riverhead Toyota
    • 13.3 mi. away
    Call
    Newly Listed
    Certified 2023 Toyota Camry XSE w/ Navigation Package
     Toyota Gold Certified

    2023 Toyota Camry

    • XSE
    • 28K mi
    35,567
    See payment
    Good Price
    No Accidents
    Riverhead Toyota
    • 13.3 mi. away
    Call
    Newly Listed
    Certified 2023 Toyota Crown Platinum
     Toyota Gold Certified

    2023 Toyota Crown

    • Platinum
    • 22K mi
     Hybrid
    38,995
    See payment
    Good Price
    No Accidents
    Riverhead Toyota
    • 13.3 mi. away
    Call
    Price Drop
    Used 2021 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2021 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 34K mi
    32,604
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Atlantic Toyota
    • 23.19 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2024 Toyota RAV4 XLE w/ Convenience Package
    Used

    2024 Toyota RAV4

    • XLE
    • 59K mi
    30,995
    See payment
    No Accidents
    Private Seller Exchange
    • 9.24 mi. away
    • Buy Online. Clean title. No Hassle
    Price Drop
    Used 2023 Toyota Highlander XLE
    Used

    2023 Toyota Highlander

    • XLE
    • 39K mi
    36,626
    See payment
    Good Price
    Dealer Fees Included
    No Accidents
    Atlantic Honda
    • 20.51 mi. away
    Call
    360°
    Used 2022 Toyota Prius LE
    Used

    2022 Toyota Prius

    • LE
    • 43K mi
     Hybrid
    16,595
    See payment
    Great Price
    PRISTINE MITSUBISHI
    • 20.88 mi. away
    Call
    Used 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander AWD
    Used

    2025 Toyota Grand Highlander

    • AWD
    • 8K mi
    42,145
    See payment
    Great Price
    No Accidents
    Nissan of Bay Shore
    • 20.23 mi. away
    Call
    Advertisement

    Used Toyota for Sale by Model

    View All Models
    <!--{"relevance":[false,{"relevanceVersion":"default"}]}-->